Pick the Best Summary
Read the story and the three summaries. Circle what each summary is: just right, too many details, or leaves out the ending.
Fresh sheet anytime. Tap New sheet or reload for a different one. Tap + for up to 10.
This is sheet #165824601.
How to do it
- Read the story.
- Read the three summaries.
- Circle just right, too many details or leaves out the ending for each one.
Teaching tip
Ask your student what they'd change to make the other two summaries just right. This sheet is aligned with Common Core RL.4.2.
About this worksheet
One of the eight stories with three summaries to label: one just right, one with too many details and one that leaves out the ending. Includes an answer key.
What kids practice
A theme is the message or lesson about life that a story shows, like "Taking small steps can help you face something scary." Stories rarely state the theme, so readers figure it out from what the characters do and learn. A summary retells the most important parts of a story or passage in a few sentences, in the reader's own words.
Watch for
- Giving a topic, like "courage," instead of a theme sentence.
- Choosing a theme that fits only one small part of the story.
- Retelling every event in a summary instead of the most important ones.
- Leaving the ending out of a summary, or adding opinions like "It was a great story."
It's free to print, with an answer key. See the full theme and summary guide for 4th grade.
More sheets in this set
- See it all
1. Theme and Summary ChartWhat a theme is, with a topic and theme side by side, three questions for finding the theme, and the Somebody Wanted But So Then frame for a summary with an example. 
2. Topic or ThemeTopics like "patience" and themes like "Good things can come to those who wait" mixed together, to mark topic or theme. Fewer, Standard or More give 8, 10 or 12. Includes an answer key.
3. Find the ThemeEight short stories, each with three theme choices to circle and lines to write a detail that shows the theme. The answer key circles the theme and gives a sample detail.
4. Theme DetectiveOne of the eight stories with four boxes to fill in: what the character wanted, what went wrong, what they learned or did, and the theme. The answer key shows sample answers.
5. Somebody Wanted But So ThenOne of the eight stories with the Somebody Wanted But So Then frame and space to write a one-sentence summary. The answer key shows sample answers.
7. Important or ExtraOne of the eight stories with six details to sort into important ones for a summary and extra ones. Includes an answer key.
8. Write a SummaryFive nonfiction passages, about honeybees, glaciers, the Pony Express, octopuses and bats, with a checklist and lines to write a 2 or 3 sentence summary. The answer key shows a sample summary.