Which Evidence Fits?
Read the opinion and the reason. Circle the evidence that best supports the reason.
Fresh sheet anytime. Tap New sheet or reload for a different one. Tap + for up to 10.
This is sheet #190124601.
How to do it
- Read the opinion and the reason.
- Read the three choices.
- Circle the evidence that best supports the reason.
Teaching tip
Talk about why the wrong choices are true but don't help the reason. This sheet is aligned with Common Core W.5.1.

About this worksheet
Opinions and reasons with three pieces of evidence to choose from. Fewer, Standard or More give 3, 4 or 5. Includes an answer key.
What kids practice
An opinion piece tells what the writer thinks and tries to convince the reader. Fifth graders give clear reasons and back up each one with evidence: facts, examples and details. They connect their ideas with linking words like for example, specifically and as a result, and they end with a conclusion that sums up their opinion.
Watch for
- Giving reasons with no evidence to back them up.
- Using a feeling, like "because I like it," as the only reason.
- Including evidence that doesn't match the reason it's under.
- Ending without restating the opinion.
It's free to print, with Fewer, Standard or More on the page and an answer key. See the full opinion with evidence guide for 5th grade.
More sheets in this set
- See it all
1. Opinion Writing ChartThe four parts of an opinion piece, an example showing how a reason differs from evidence, eight linking words, and how to tell a fact from an opinion.
2. Fact or Opinion?Facts and opinions mixed together, including opinions that sound like facts. Fewer, Standard or More give 8, 10 or 12. Includes an answer key.
3. Reason or Evidence?Opinions, each with two reasons and the evidence for each, to sort. Fewer, Standard or More give 2, 3 or 4 opinions. Includes an answer key.
5. Strong or Weak Reason?Opinions with strong and weak reasons to judge. Weak reasons are off topic or just a feeling. Fewer, Standard or More give 6, 8 or 10. The answer key says why.
6. Linking Words for OpinionsPairs of sentences with a blank for linking words like for example, in addition or as a result. Fewer, Standard or More give 6, 8 or 10. Includes an answer key.
7. Opinion Essay PlannerA one-page planner with room for an opinion, three reasons each with evidence and a source, a bank of linking words, and a conclusion.
Helpful supplies (affiliate links)
Simple supplies that go with these sheets.
Kids' newspaper subscription
Real news stories and opinion pieces for kids.
Find it on AmazonWriting guide for kids
How to plan, write and fix an essay.
Find it on AmazonChildren's thesaurus
Find words that mean the same, the opposite, or something stronger.
Find it on AmazonHighlighter tape
Mark words and lift the tape off again.
Find it on Amazon